1% for the Planet: Next Phase

Meet the Team:

Team of 1 UX Designers and 2 UX Researchers and 1 UX Writer

My Role:

Contract Senior UX Designer

Work with Research and UX Writer to uncover why usage of 1% for the Planet carbon tracking severe drop off at 3 months, and update user experience to remedy, and concluded with user interviews to validate design decisions.

The Why

Rationale: A product like this helps us develop the bank’s growing brand as "the environmental bank".

Marketing and forecasting efforts in 2019 revealed that Bank of the West was well positioned to corner a growing segment — specifically the environmentally-conscious. We then partnered with 1% for the Planet and Doconomy (for carbon data) to create this new experience in Mobile.

Customer Research

Timeline:

A year after launch, Research interviewed a group of customers, as product wellness check, to understand their experience with the account and the carbon-calculator feature offered in Mobile.

Research Process:

We gathered account data on deposit amounts, attrition rates, and carbon footprint-tracker views, then interviewed 11 customers with the most views on their footprint tracker.

Key Questions:

How well, and how often, is the feature being used?

Is the product meeting user expectations?

What do our customers think?

Analytics Indicate:
Usage of the carbon calculator dropped off significantly after the first few months.
Customers were confused on a number of issues:
  • What does a pound of CO2e actually mean?
  • How does my footprint compare to other people — and what is “good” vs “bad” here?How does carbon calculation work?
  • What am I to do with this information?
  • How does BOTW donate or do good with this account?

3 Customer Categories Discovered

ASPIRING — “I want...”

2 of 11 Customers

Environmentally conscious

Opened account for sustainability benefits and CO2e feature

Wishes to learn more

Wants to do more

AGREEABLE — “Sounds good.”

2 of 11 Customers

Aware of product value

Considers CO2 feature as a nice-to-have, but not an essential part of their banking experience

May overlook the details

CONFUSED — “I have what?”

7 of 11 Customers

Simply opened a new checking account

Not aware of the 1%FTP contributing benefits

Making no use of the CO2e Doconomy data

Opportunities for Improvement

Reinforce & Support

Build credibility and awareness with more information about the carbon footprint tracker. Offer more information about how the Carbon Footprint calculator works — and show where the data is coming from.

Clarity & Context

Provide more context for CO2 footprint. One customer thought they were being charged a fee  on their account. Carbon data needs to be presented in a way that customers understand what the numbers represents.

Enhance & Evolve

Build a richer experience for our 1% FTP customers with better ways to understand the impact of their accounts contribution to the bigger picture. Explore new ways to improve the user experience.

Workshop

Meet the Particpants:

Team of 1 Principle UX Designer and 2 UX Researchers and 2 Project Managers, 1 Program Manager, 2 Reactive Native Engineers, 1 Senior marketer.

My Role:

I designed and lead ideation workshop and brought together a cross functional Bank of the West team.

Reasoning for workshop was the Bank of the West culture holds sustainability close to their hearts. Many ideas and thoughts go unheard without the proper space to facilitate meaningful conversations. Workshop was an adaptation of crazy 8 exercise.

Customer Journey Map

Collaboration with UX Research Team to develop customer journey map. Map helped identify pain points and areas for improvement and enabled us to develop targeted solutions to address these issues.

Design

Previous Design Screen and Issues Identified

Issues Identified:

User testing revealed participants confused charge amount and carbon footprint number, expressed concern that they where being charge as the numbers are very close in proximity. One participant went as far as wanting to cancel account in concern she was being charged for her carbon footprint.

Additionally, it was found that information about what a carbon footprint is was difficult to locate and not easily accessible, as it was hidden in the settings. In monitored testing, one participant stated that it was not possible to find this information and believed that it did not exist within the system.

Questions that arose from testing

- What is a CO2 footprint?

- What is a lb of CO2?

-How does my footprint compare to others?

-How does the carbon calculator work?

-How do I change my behavior?

-What does BOTW do with the donations?

Previous Screen below

Updating the Design

Greater Clarity in Detail

Research participants expressed confusion regarding what a carbon footprint entailed, and how specific carbon values relate to their transactions.

Considering the detailed view of a user’s transaction history, we recommend visually separating the CO2e value.

Bringing more clarity and scalability to the transaction scroll.With less clutter in the data expression, we can enhance the experience — with less confusion — as pointed out by Research.

Design Proposal:

Drill Down: No more confusing graph, customer can drill down to understand further.

Transaction list item confusion: The numbers stack was hard to read for customers.

Onboarding with Support, Empathy & Learning

Our aim is to improve the UX in simple ways that address the research findings — calling for more education and engagement opportunities around the carbon data and our relationship with 1%FTP.

As Mobile takes on new 1%FTP customers, we consider the user’s onboarding experience to be paramount. Tutorial slides can offer a quick orientation and reminder of product value, whereas other opportunities can provide more abilities to learn about carbon impacts.

Design Proposal:

Intro Cards: Let’s start with more clarity and understanding — employing a concise reinforcement of value.

Carbon Conversions

“What is a pound of carbon, anyway?”

Research participants expressed confusion about what a pound of carbon is, in more realistic terms...A carbon converter can help explain what an amount (of carbon equivalence) actually means by creating a simple comparison. For example, 100 lbs of carbon is approximately equal to 100 miles driven by an average vehicle (according to recent EPA calculations). Such conversions can also offer more constructive comparisons, asking,

“How many trees would it take to offset this much carbon?”

Design Proposal:

Express Comparable Metrics, compare a pound of carbon to something users can understand. With a tap, users can change their optics to see the picture a little differently. The reality of the carbon impact is constant, but a change in perspective can help the true impact resonate with users.

Learning more: Interest in the data can lead you to learn more about the source, enriching this experience.

Take Aways

Research findings have indicated a need for more clarity and better touch points on data/partnership

Design has explored new opportunities with a goal to enhance the UX and engagement opportunities

Collectively we believe such efforts to evolve the experience will result in greater product success